But where should Romania stand?

Romania

Which side should Romania take?

Fotó: Tamás Attila

Against the backdrop of a transforming world order following Donald Trump’s presidential election victory, many may feel the ground falling out from under them – but few countries feel it as intensely as Romania.

Balogh Levente

2025. március 31., 18:432025. március 31., 18:43

2025. március 31., 18:512025. március 31., 18:51

While the strategic partnership with the United States, along with NATO and EU membership, has so far been the most important pillar of Romania’s foreign and security policy doctrine, this very pillar now seems to be faltering. One reason for this is that Washington seems to be devoting less and less attention to Europe, and the other is specifically related to Romania: namely, the annulment of last year’s presidential election.

As is widely known, US Vice President J. D. Vance has repeatedly lashed out at officials in Bucharest, condemning the annulment of the election results as an affront to democracy; he has also commented that a democracy that falls vulnerable to a TikTok campaign could be called into question.

Then, tech billionaire Elon Musk, the head of the newly-established DOGE, tasked with making US government spending more efficient, took Bucharest to task and scrubbed the floor with justice officials over the criminal case against Călin Georgescu. The latest bombshell is that, contrary to initial plans, the US visa waiver for Romanian citizens will not come into effect at the end of March. Although they are attempting to justify this with the Trump administration’s general change in strategy towards migration, it is hard not to assume that there could be a connection between the two cases.

Especially in light of the fact that last weekend the US embassy in Bucharest also made sure to send their message loud and clear: first, they shared Vance’s critical words without any particular comment or justification, and then they warned of sanctions against illegal entry to the USA. This was followed by a Fox News report on the increase in the number of Romanian border violators arriving from Canada on the very day the visa waiver was postponed.

To understand why the torrent of criticism from Washington against the Romanian authorities caused such a shock in Bucharest, it is worth recalling the Romanian perception of security. According to this, Bucharest regularly seeks the favor of the biggest power with the biggest influence in the region and tries to serve its needs without critique – and if it sees that the given „boss” begins to waver, it immediately switches sides to the power that seems to be the new deciding factor in the region for the coming period. Now a situation has arisen where it seems that Romania has reached a crossroads and must decide where to take a stand in the conflict that seems to be developing between the United States and the majority of European leaders.

All this is taking place in a situation where Romania is still unable to protect itself from external threats on its own, but without the United States, Europe as a whole is not yet able to fully guarantee its own security.

Romanian politicians and other public figures are partly responsible for the deterioration of relations with Washington, as they apparently did not take the time to provide the USA with a detailed explanation of why the election had to be annulled. On the other hand, it could also be that the new administration is no longer that interested in what happened and why, and that the criticisms of Bucharest are part of a larger strategy: the Trump administration assessing that it will not be able to cooperate as closely as it would like with traditional European parties.

This can be attributed to both ideological and personal reasons. It is worth remembering that from the beginning of his first term, the left-liberal side belittled Trump whenever it had the chance, and over time, the former conservative side, which now essentially follows the same liberal ideology, also joined in. All this continued and even intensified after Trump's election defeat. And Trump and his staff have not forgotten this. For this reason, it seems that they are trying, on the one hand, to establish and strengthen closer ties with European right-wing parties that are not in the EPP, and, on the other hand, to ensure that their new partners perform as well as possible in the elections. (This is an old tradition – just ask Cubans, Chileans, and citizens of many other countries around the world about what it's like when the United States intervenes to help its own people come to power. But the operation carried out during the Biden administration against the legally elected Hungarian government is not all that different from this practice.)

The Trump administration's good relationship with the Hungarian government is well-known and nothing new, but Washington's support for AfD in the run-up to the German elections is already part of the new doctrine.

And it may also be related to the fact that Vance and Musk can't help but chide the Romanian authorities, since they mowed down a candidate who, in principle, represents the sovereignist right, as opposed to mainstream politics. Of course, we know very well that this has little to do with reality, as he is a far-right, neo-fascist, conspiracy theorist. However, Washington hardly cares what kind of leader is at the helm of a distant vassal state, as long as American interests are served in every way, and despite the Romanian press riding Georgescu’s pro-Russian rhetoric, he has spoken about closer cooperation with the United States on several occasions. Moreover, it is difficult to deny that the Romanian authorities invalidated the presidential election using methods worthy of the Third World, and to this day they are still obliged to make the detailed and precise reasoning public, continuing to seriously violate the right of citizens to get an accurate picture of the operation of state institutions and the background to their decisions.

Based on all this, the embassy's warnings, the news about Romanian border violators, and the postponement of visa-free travel can be interpreted as a not-so-discreet warning that the authorities should not even consider interfering in the course of the elections by any means – if, for example, voters decide at the polls that George Simion should be the next president, then this must be accepted. Although it is a fact that this would not be a very favorable scenario for us Hungarians.

And if the EU agrees with the steps taken by the Romanian authorities, then it is easy to claim that democracy is flailing in the whole of the EU.

(Which is not completely unfounded, but this incident is not exactly proof of that). In any event, this week's leaked Signal group chat conversation about the strike against the Houthis in Yemen also perfectly indicates how the current American administration views Europe. Vice President Vance's indignation that Washington is once again the one to pull the Europeans out of the fray, and Defense Secretary Hegseth's counterclaim that it is pitiful that Europeans are enjoying American security guarantees as freeloaders, may seem shocking, but unfortunately it is difficult to refute.

Although some suggest that the leak may have been intentional, it is rather unlikely. However, it is certainly useful for European officials to finally see clearly: the Trump administration genuinely believes that the countries of the old continent have become unacceptably comfortable and have taken the American protective umbrella so much for granted that they believed they could indefinitely postpone the development of their own defense capabilities. It seems that Romanian officials have already made the switch and realized that they are not equals with Washington as neither an adversary nor partner, but they cannot find effective protection in Western Europe either.

This is probably why Acting President Ilie Bolojan, in an almost apologetic interview, partially confirmed the US Vice President's criticism of Romanian democracy. And Prime Minister Ciolacu also took a jab at the coalition partner liberals and made a gesture to Washington when, following the postponement of the visa waiver, he said that Foreign Minister Emil Hurezeanu is an old-fashioned diplomat who can find common ground with Europeans – meaning the liberals and the populist, former conservative, mainstream that has joined them – but not with Trump and his circle.

In the meantime, Bucharest is trying to keep a foot in both camps, as it does not dare to openly oppose the EU.

For instance, Romania voted for the proposal to postpone the effort to end the war in Ukraine without a word of opposition, just as it is participating in the negotiations on further military support for Ukraine. True, according to Acting President Ilie Bolojan, with the stipulation that Romania will not send soldiers to Ukraine, it will only serve as a logistical hub for the supplies and troops to be sent there. (In this regard, we would like to draw his and his staff's attention to the fact that this does not make Romania any less a party to a potential conflict, in fact… A logistical hub is no less valuable a target for the enemy force than the units fighting on the front line. In fact, it may even be more valuable, since the latter can be more easily crushed by eliminating supply hubs and routes.)

At the same time, it seems that they are more cautious with Macron's French saber-rattling, as is also indicated by the fact that Romania does not want to extend the French nuclear shield. After all, Bucharest is most likely aware that back in the Cold War, the so-called MAD (literally meaning crazy, but actually Mutually Assured Destruction) was the balance and the guarantee that no nuclear power would dare to take the risk of launching a first strike. However, when the French side has 290 nuclear warheads and the Russian side has 5,800, you would have to be delusional to not realize that this does not exactly signify parity, even if only a third of Russian warheads can actually be deployed…

So for now, Bucharest is waiting and trying to maintain the best possible relationship with both sides. Then, over time, it will be decided whether the foundations of a new American-European system of relations will be laid, in which economic and military cooperation remain strong, but Europe takes on a greater share of its own defense.

What is certain is that the conditions will not be set on this side of the ocean for the time being. And in this case, it doesn't hurt to be on good terms with the person who dictates the terms.

korábban írtuk

De hova álljanak a románok?
De hova álljanak a románok?

A Donald Trump elnökválasztási győzelme nyomán átalakulóban levő világrend kapcsán sokan érezhetik úgy, hogy kicsúszik a lábuk alól a talaj – de kevés ország érezheti annyira intenzíven, mint Románia.

szóljon hozzá! Hozzászólások

Hírlevél

Iratkozzon fel hírlevelünkre, hogy elsőként értesüljön a hírekről!

Ezek is érdekelhetik

A rovat további cikkei

2025. március 25., kedd

Young Hungarian From Cluj-Napoca Named Among the World's Best Sports Photographers

Tamás Horváth, aged 18, from Cluj-Napoca (Kolozsvár), has been included in the list of the best sports photographers in the world, after his work was selected for the longlist in the Sport Media Awards.

Young Hungarian From Cluj-Napoca Named Among the World's Best Sports Photographers
2025. március 09., vasárnap

Hungary’s Spa Tourism and Romania’s Shopping Tourism Increased Following Schengen Accession

Romania's accession to the Schengen area of ​​the European Union this year meant a two-way increase in traffic free from internal border controls: spa tourism in Hungary and shopping tourism in Romania increased in January.

Hungary’s Spa Tourism and Romania’s Shopping Tourism Increased Following Schengen Accession
2025. február 26., szerda

Real solutions instead of just commentary: Deputy Ombudsman Zsolt Molnár on his successes and the most Transylvanian cases

The Ombudsman's Office, also known as the People's Advocate, receives many complaints from members of the Hungarian community in Romania and from the regions inhabited by Hungarians – but the vast majority of these do not concern minority rights.

Real solutions instead of just commentary: Deputy Ombudsman Zsolt Molnár on his successes and the most Transylvanian cases
2025. február 19., szerda

Iconic altarpiece of St. Michael’s Church to return as restoration is finished

The historic Baroque altarpiece is being restored and will be displayed once again in the Saint Michael Church in Cluj-Napoca (Kolozsvár). The identity of the artist was discovered following the recently completed restoration.

Iconic altarpiece of St. Michael’s Church to return as restoration is finished
2025. február 15., szombat

Auf wiedersehen, Iohannis!

Personally, I think it is right that the head of state has made up his mind and is stepping down from the presidency. There is just one problem: this gesture has come too little too late from Klaus Iohannis.

Auf wiedersehen, Iohannis!
Auf wiedersehen, Iohannis!
2025. február 15., szombat

Auf wiedersehen, Iohannis!

2025. február 13., csütörtök

„What is not prohibited by law can be displayed” – Disputes Over Village Name Signs and the Szekler Flag Persist

For over a decade, Imre Vass, the mayor of Makfalva in Mureș (Maros) County, has been battling Romanian nationalist attacks in a municipality where the proportion of the Romanian population is very small.

„What is not prohibited by law can be displayed” – Disputes Over Village Name Signs and the Szekler Flag Persist
2025. február 13., csütörtök

Buying Property in Cluj-Napoca is a Luxury. Is it a Bubble or Reality? – Experts Share Their Views on the Outlook

It’s long been common knowledge at this point that property prices in Cluj-Napoca are the highest in the country, rivaling those in major Western European cities.

Buying Property in Cluj-Napoca is a Luxury. Is it a Bubble or Reality?  – Experts Share Their Views on the Outlook
2025. február 13., csütörtök

The Government is Recklessly Spending Money, the Deficit is Concerning – Says Csaba Bálint, Returning Member of the Central Bank’s Board

„Although it was anticipated that this year’s ‘super-election year’ would witness unprecedented spending due to continuous campaign giveaways, the Bucharest government has spent even more than expected. As a result, the budget deficit, which was high to begin with, is expected to rise to around 8%,” said Csaba Bálint, a returning member of the Board of Directors of the National Bank of Romania (BNR), in an interview with Krónika.

The Government is Recklessly Spending Money, the Deficit is Concerning – Says Csaba Bálint, Returning Member of the Central Bank’s Board
2025. február 12., szerda

RMDSZ, governing, and the tough times ahead

Though the noise of the upcoming parliamentary and presidential election campaigns diverts attention from critical issues, voters should approach the November-December elections aware that tough times are ahead for Romania in 2025.

RMDSZ, governing, and the tough times ahead
RMDSZ, governing, and the tough times ahead
2025. február 12., szerda

RMDSZ, governing, and the tough times ahead

2025. február 12., szerda

Who will save Hungarians from this administrative lunacy and assimilation?

We hope that the leaders of RMDSZ (Democratic Alliance of Hungarians in Romania) will be gracious enough to send a bouquet of flowers and a box of chocolates to Elena Lasconi.

Who will save Hungarians from this administrative lunacy and assimilation?